# 5 4 and 5-star hotels in Isle of Islay (2026)

> 5 4 and 5-star hotels in Isle of Islay, best reviewed first — including Port Charlotte Hotel. Ratings, locations and details.

Source: https://staycation.co.uk/isle-of-islay/hotels/four-and-five-star (Staycation.co.uk). Cite the source page, not this text version.

5 listed · best reviewed first

Updated 20 August 2026 · Ratings from Google · [All hotels and B&Bs in Isle of Islay](https://staycation.co.uk/isle-of-islay/hotels)

[4-5 star 5](https://staycation.co.uk/isle-of-islay/hotels/four-and-five-star)

[Isle of Islay Port Charlotte Hotel ★ 4.5 (601) A characterful 4-star hotel on the shore of Loch Indaal, known for its seafood restaurant and extensive whisky list.](https://staycation.co.uk/isle-of-islay/hotels/port-charlotte-hotel) [Isle of Islay Another Place, The Machrie ★ 4.6 (396) A contemporary design hotel on a championship links course beside seven miles of dune-backed beach on Islay's west coast.](https://staycation.co.uk/isle-of-islay/hotels/another-place-the-machrie) [Isle of Islay Glenegedale House ★ 4.9 (131) A five-star guest house with breathtaking Atlantic and Mull of Oa views, midway between Bowmore and Port Ellen.](https://staycation.co.uk/isle-of-islay/hotels/glenegedale-house) [Isle of Islay Islay House ★ 4.4 (166) A restored 17th-century country house set in walled gardens at Bridgend, once the seat of the Campbells of Islay.](https://staycation.co.uk/isle-of-islay/hotels/islay-house) [Isle of Islay Kilmeny Country House ★ 5.0 (80) A five-star Gold guest house on a working farm near Ballygrant, run by the same family for over three decades.](https://staycation.co.uk/isle-of-islay/hotels/kilmeny-country-house)

## Quick answers

How many 4 and 5-star hotels are there in Isle of Islay?+

We list 5 in Isle of Islay. The best-reviewed are shown first.

Which 4 and 5-star hotels in Isle of Islay are best reviewed?+

By Google rating weighted by the number of reviews: Port Charlotte Hotel (4.5/5, 601 reviews), Another Place, The Machrie (4.6/5, 396 reviews) and Glenegedale House (4.9/5, 131 reviews).

Is this list up to date?+

It is built live from our listings; ratings come from Google and each venue page shows when its details were last checked. Always confirm with the venue before travelling.